Explore galaxies.im
andromeda.galaxies.im
Hubble and VAR!

The star that changed the universe

One night, one photographic plate and one exclamation mark.

How this site works. Every fact is in our own words and linked to its source, beside it. Where good sources disagree, we show each version in a “Sources differ” box.

Before Hubble

It was mentioned as early as 965 CE in the Book of the Fixed Stars by the Islamic astronomer al-Ṣūfī. Britannica

It was rediscovered in 1612, soon after the telescope was invented, by the German astronomer Simon Marius. Britannica Marius said it looked like the light of a candle seen through a horn. Britannica

For centuries astronomers thought it was part of the Milky Way, a ‘spiral nebula’, hence the old name Andromeda Nebula. Britannica

As far back as 1912, astronomers realised Andromeda, then thought to be only a nebula, was heading our way. NASA, 2025

Step through it: October 1923

Pick a step to see what happened.

All five steps are shown below.

Our sketch of the idea behind Hubble’s famous plate, not a copy of it.Drawing: our own, simplified and not to scale

Step 1: An island universe?

In the early 1900s most astronomers thought the Milky Way was a single ‘island universe’ with nothing observable beyond it. NASA, V1

Andromeda was catalogued as just one of many faint, fuzzy ‘spiral nebulae’. NASA, V1

Step 2: The night of 5 October 1923

On the night of 5 October 1923 Edwin Hubble began an observing run that lasted into the early hours of 6 October. NASA, V1

In poor conditions he made a 45-minute exposure and marked three suspected novae, exploding stars, with an ‘N’. NASA, V1

Step 3: One “nova” misbehaves

Comparing that plate with older ones, he found one ‘nova’ dimmed and brightened far faster than a nova should. NASA, V1

Step 4: VAR!

He crossed out the ‘N’ and wrote ‘VAR!’, for variable, with an exclamation mark. NASA, V1

The star, Hubble variable number one or V1, is a Cepheid variable in Andromeda’s outer regions. NASA, V1

Step 5: The debate is settled

V1 showed that Andromeda lies beyond our galaxy, and settled the debate about the spiral nebulae. NASA, V1

By the end of 1924 Hubble had found 36 variable stars in Andromeda, 12 of them Cepheids. NASA, V1

A black and white studio portrait of a man in a suit and tie, with a pipe
Edwin Hubble in 1931.Picture: Johan Hagemeyer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped and resized)

Why one star was enough

A Cepheid brightens and fades in a regular pattern, like a lighthouse, and was already known to be a reliable distance marker. NASA, V1

V1’s rhythm: slow fade, sharp rise (our sketch of the shape, not real data).Drawing: our own, simplified and not to scale

V1 takes a little over 31 days to brighten and fade once. NASA, V1

NASA says Edwin Hubble measured Andromeda’s vast distance by finding a variable star that served as a ‘milepost marker’. NASA, 2012

What happened next

Harlow Shapley, who believed the nebulae were part of the Milky Way, reportedly said of Hubble’s letter: “Here is the letter that destroyed my universe.” NASA, V1

From them he worked out a distance of 900,000 light-years; better measurements later moved it to about 2 million. NASA, V1

Britannica: only in the 1920s did Hubble show conclusively that Andromeda is a separate galaxy. Britannica

A collection of three panels: Andromeda as a whole, a close-up of a crowded star field with one star circled, and old and new views of that star
Snapshots of V1, the star that changed the universe, taken nearly 90 years apart, with a portrait of its home galaxy.Picture: NASA, ESA, Z. Levay and the Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA), CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped and resized)

A tribute, 88 years on

An astronomer at the Space Telescope Science Institute called V1 “the most important star in the history of cosmology”. NASA, V1

In 2010 and 2011 amateur astronomers tracked V1 and the Hubble Space Telescope photographed it again, as a tribute. NASA, V1

Cepheids are still the first rung on the ‘cosmic distance ladder’ astronomers use for far more distant galaxies. NASA, V1

A dense field of tiny stars with soft brown swirls of dust and small blue clusters
The star field around V1 in Andromeda’s outer disc, photographed by the Hubble Space Telescope.Picture: NASA, ESA and the Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA), CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped and resized)
Our opinion

Our view: the most important exclamation mark in science was written on a photographic plate after a night at the telescope, by someone who could have just gone to bed.

Next: inside Andromeda →